What Actually Sells Novels in 2026

One Year into My Author Era, What I’ll Do Again, and What I’ll Skip for Book 2

In my last post, The Truth About Marketing Fiction No One Says Out Loud, I covered some hard truths about selling books: the market is more crowded than ever (with fewer people reading), fiction is entertainment (and needs to be marketed that way), word of mouth still wins, and success as an author requires playing the long game.

I also promised to share a post-mortem of what actually sold books in my debut year as a way to celebrate entering my backlist author era. This is that post.

But first, some honesty from someone in the trenches: If you don’t really love writing books, my unsolicited advice is to do something easier and more lucrative with your time.

In the case of being a novelist, the juice is only worth the squeeze if you love the act of squeezing.

Still here? Then it’s safe to say you’ve also got the fever, and the only remedy is that clickity-clack sound of your fingers on the keyboard. This one’s for you.

Like most first-time authors, I had no clue what to expect from a sales perspective. I knew it would be tough and take time to build a readership. Still, the delusion that we may be the one who gets lucky with a viral breakout gets to all of us at some point. (How could it not when those are the messages we’re flooded with all over social media?)

Here’s the reality, because I’m all about transparency and don’t think there’s enough of it in this space: BookScan found that about half of the new releases sold by the biggest publishers sold fewer than 1,000 print copies, and 14.7% sold fewer than 12 copies. As a no-name author with a boutique press + Simon & Schuster distribution, I’ve sold roughly 600 paperbacks in my first year with the strategies below, which puts my sales in the same range as about half of the new releases from the biggest publishers.

One important caveat: at least 200 sales came from initial orders driven by the Simon & Schuster sales team. Having a distributor behind your book helps initial sales a lot. What I don’t know, and will never know, is how many of those books went into physical bookstores versus to online retailers. If they mostly sold on Amazon, my marketing was most likely the reason.

(I’m only including paperback numbers to compare apples to apples with the stat above. Since I only receive two royalty statements a year, and don’t have backend visibility into my numbers, I’m basing this off of sales of my own physical copies, and the statements I’ve received to date.)

With all of that, here’s what actually moved books—and cost NOTHING.

Free and Worked

Breaking News: Old school marketing still works!

If you only remember one thing from this, I hope it’s this:

TAP YOUR LOCAL COMMUNITY & PERSONAL NETWORK

The people who already know, like, and trust you are going to be your first readers, and the ones who help spread the word about your book(s).

Email All of Your Friends, Family, & Acquaintances from Your Personal Email the Week the Book is Available

Tell them the book is out and ask them to help spread the word.

Include one link to buy it online.

Make it EASY for them to order it. (This is always a good rule of thumb.)

Include a short blurb about the book, why you wrote it, and thank them for their support over the years, etc.

Honestly, this was the thing I felt the most awkward doing, but it produced one of the most measurable bumps in sales I could track via Amazon’s sales rankings. It’s also your best shot at getting on an Amazon Bestseller List in a niche category if you don’t already have an email list of readers.

Hot Tip I Wish I’d Known: Amazon doesn’t add pre-orders to your first week’s sales, so if getting your book on an Amazon bestseller list is one of your goals (which is much more doable than you probably realize) focus on first day/week sales instead of pre-orders.

In the email I sent, I also asked my friends and family if they knew anyone in the media who may be able to help spread the word about my book. A friend referred me to a podcast this way. Others helped me get media features.

At the end of the email, I promised to be respectful of their personal inbox, so I also included my author newsletter opt-in link so they could decide if they wanted to stay up to date on my authorly adventures moving forward.

An Important Side Note About Friends, Family, & Feelings:

Some will read your book(s), and some won’t.

Don’t take it personally.

You are not your work.

And just because someone loves you, that doesn’t mean they are your ideal reader.

More Ways to Sell Locally

My local bookstores and shops were having a hard time getting their orders of my book from the wholesaler initially, but I had a few boxes of my own copies on hand, so we did 60/40 split for signed copies of the book. I sold through four boxes of books this way.

Host a signing event. Do it in partnership with a bookstore (make sure to bring extra copies in case the store runs out), or host an event yourself to make 100% of the net off of your print copies

Pitch to local book clubs. Start with who you know and offer to join their meeting in person or via Zoom if they don’t live locally. I’ve sold at least 100 books because of book clubs. People love supporting local authors and it’s really fun to get to finally talk about the book with readers. Bonus? New friends!

The same goes for local media. Pitch them yourself. Work your contacts (you probably know someone who can get you to the right person). I saw at least 2 weeks of increased daily sales on Amazon after local articles came out about my book, and I spent zero on media publicity.

Reach New Readers (and Stay in Touch) for Free

Use Substack as a FREE way to build your author newsletter

There’s a common expression in the digital marketing space: The Money is in Your List.
There’s a good reason the experts focus so much on the importance of email marketing: The average email open rate is 15-25% of your list, as opposed to only about 4% of followers who will see your post on Instagram (Facebook is even lower, with only a 2% organic reach average).

(Something worth noting, my Substack open rates are almost 2x higher than when I used another email platform—consistently around 30%. In my experience, they’re less likely to go to SPAM or promotions.)

This platform is such an incredible resource for authors. You don’t have to pay a dime to use it, you can network with other authors, connect with readers, learn about the industry, and the algorithm sends subscribers your way once it figures out who you are and what you’re about.

I’m not saying it happens overnight. I’ve been writing on this platform for over a year, but in the past month, a random note I wrote and posted in one minute, along with my last article, added 171 new subscribers to my email list for free.

Tip: Do export your list every so often just in case something goes wonky with the platform. I’ve heard horror stories of glitches that cost people all of their subscribers.

Now that we’ve covered FREE, here are the things I spent money on that I’ll do again.

Paid and Worth It

Goodreads Giveaway:

(On sale for $99 when I did it)

I got over 5,000 sign-ups on my giveaway offering 10 signed paperbacks.

This automatically added Annie in Retrospect to 5,000 people’s Want to Read list.

To be honest, I’m not sure how many of those converted to eventual buyers, but it was incredible visibility for the book, and the copies I sent out to winners have gotten me reviews (which are gold).

You can do a print or digital Goodreads Giveaway. From what I’ve personally seen myself and via my author network, print copies convert more signups. But, if the goal is getting more reviews, offering more digital copies to more readers may be the smarter play (and there’s no mailing expense). Pros and cons for sure. I’ll most likely do the digital giveaway for Leena Gets a Rewrite to compare results.

Book Mail Tip: If you’re in the US, mail books from your local post office via Media Mail. It’s only about $5 this way.

Engaging Creators on Instagram

(Cost: Books + Postage)

If you’re a fiction author, creators who love your niche and have built a following sharing books are on Instagram.

Here’s What I Do and Recommend:

-Follow creators who review books in your genre (psst . . . make sure they’re human)

-Like, comment, and share their content (a.k.a. connect like a human)

-Offer to send them a copy of your book (never ask for anything in return)

-If they say yes, include a handwritten note. Close it by saying that if they enjoy the book, you’d be grateful for a review

That’s it.

Write the cost of the book and shipping off as a marketing expense. It’s way cheaper than paying a publicity company.

(I’m recommending sending the physical book to Bookstagrammers because it’s a visual platform. You can always ask if they prefer digital.)

A side note about Swag:

Skip expensive swag boxes. A bookmark with a QR code to shop is enough. Assembling physical ARC kits for booksellers and press was a waste of money on my debut.

Paid and Not Worth It

NetGalley Reviews

I paid $180 for 3 months of NetGalley access for my ARCs in a Hail Mary that I’d somehow manage to get a major review from a large publication.

I’d heard their reviewers are not well vetted and harsh. Both turned out to be true, and it crushed a lot of my pre-release excitement.

Unless you have extremely thick skin and care more about the number of reviews than your rating, I’d skip it, especially for a debut novelist.

For my next book, I’m collecting ARC readers via Bookstagram and Substack, where I know they read my genre.

(If this also happened to you, take heart: most readers haven’t agreed with those early critics. In my experience, your average Amazon rating will likely land at least 1.5 to 2 stars higher.)

Trade Publication Ads

I paid $350 for a thumbnail ad in a trade magazine because it would be at the Frankfurt Book Fair in front of booksellers. I won’t do this again for book 2. There’s just no way of knowing the ROI. It would take an insane amount of bookstores ordering my book to make up for the cost of the ad, and I don’t have enough visibility into where my sales are coming from to know if it made a difference.

A Publicity Company for Influencer Outreach

(Cost: way too much—let’s just say it was in the thousands)

I’d been off of Instagram for a few years before my book came out, so I hired a publicity company to run an influencer campaign for Annie. They did a great job, and it led to awesome visibility and reviews, but it’s hard to say how much it moved the needle on actual sales. (I can confidently say whatever sales did come from the campaign they didn’t come close to covering the spend). My biggest takeaway: the reader community on Instagram is awesome, and you don’t need a publicist or marketing team to reach them. (See my DIY approach above and save yourself thousands.)

Skipped On Purpose

Reviews, Awards, & Events, oh my! $$$

I chose not to pay for the most expensive trade reviews (which can run in the hundreds and upwards of $1000), and I’m glad I didn’t.

In my unfiltered opinion, trade reviews don’t sell books to the average reader, and neither do the paid-to-enter awards that most of us get pitched. (Of course, the big ones like the Booker or the Pulitzer move books, but that’s a different conversation.) Trade reviews matter more to booksellers and librarians deciding what to stock than to readers deciding what to buy.

That being said, this is where knowing your genre and your personal priorities becomes essential. Because even though we’re here to talk about selling books, sales numbers aren’t the only thing that matters.

For example, if you write historical fiction and really care about getting a review from Kirkus no matter how the review turns out, then the cost is worth it to you.

The same goes for paying money to submit your book for awards. For some authors, awards are way more of a motivator than sales. If it matters to YOU, then it’s worth it. Just know it probably won’t move the needle enough from a sales perspective to make up for the cost.

I also didn’t spend money on attending book fairs, festivals, or signing events. I have three kids under 12 along with unpredictable health challenges that make traveling and setting up booths for events difficult. With the costs of travel and attending events being so high, and my personal desire to do them being so low, I couldn’t justify the return on the investment.

I’d rather invest the time and money I’d spend on events on producing an audio book in order to extend my stories to more readers. (An audiobook for Annie in Retrospect is currently in production, so stay tuned!)

Quick Note About Amazon & Meta Ads: I did not run any for Annie in Retrospect in its first year and here’s why: From my experience and training with ads, I know they work best with multiple books: you discount (or give away) the first book to drive sales of the next one, and so on. So I chose to wait until I felt like I could run an ad funnel that would actually turn a profit. That being said, with my eBook now on sale for 99 cents, I’m experimenting with Amazon ads in real time to reach more readers with the deal, while understanding the sales won’t cover the cost. I’ll report back with anything useful!

The Bottom Line

Here’s what a year taught me: the things that sold my book weren’t the things I lost sleep over a year ago. Not getting the “big name” trade reviews. Not the launch-week numbers. It was a friend telling a friend. A book club that led to another book club. A reader who finished Annie and asked when the next one was coming.

I’ve learned readers don’t care about the things the industry tends to get in a tizzy about (reviews, awards, our launch strategy, first month sales, etc.)

They don’t care when your book came out.

They’re buying a book because their friend recommended it to them. Or because they liked the cover, and the back cover copy did its job. Or because they already read your last book and loved it.

So, if you’re still enjoying the squeeze, keep squeezing. Write the next book. Stay in touch with the people who loved the last one. Human to human, one reader at a time.

Love, Kristina

P.S. I’d love to know, what actually sold books for you? What are your repeats and skips?

Next
Next

The Truth About Selling Fiction No One Says Out Loud